Which type of tower crane is right for my project?
Choosing a tower crane depends, among other factors, on how it is designed and on the movements it can make to bring the load where it needs to go.
On Flat-Top cranes, the jib stays horizontal and a trolley travels along it to position the load. On luffing jib cranes, the jib itself changes its angle to adjust the working radius.
These differences in operation have a direct impact on how each crane can be installed and operated, especially when the available space, the presence of obstacles or the characteristics of the jobsite constrain the work.
To understand this better, let´s look at how each type of crane responds to a range of common construction scenarios.
A jobsite that needs a single crane in an open setting
On standalone jobsites, with no nearby buildings or restrictions limiting the slewing radius or the working area, and where a single crane can meet the needs of the project, Flat-Top tower cranes are often a particularly good fit.
Their horizontal jib can cover large working areas, and the trolley´s travel speed helps achieve high productivity when distributing materials.
That is why they are common on industrial projects, logistics hubs and large infrastructure projects, where materials and equipment need to be moved across extensive working areas.
You can learn more about their features and applications in our Flat-Top tower crane section.
Several cranes on the same jobsite
When several tower cranes work on the same jobsite and their working areas overlap, planning their heights and radii is essential to avoid interference.
In this kind of setup, Flat-Top cranes have an advantage: since they have no tower head or pendants, they require less clearance between jibs than other designs. This can reduce the tower height required and, in certain configurations, optimize transportation and erection costs.
However, when the cranes are so close together that the jib tip of the lower crane could interfere with the mast of the crane above it, luffing jib cranes can offer an alternative.
Their ability to raise the jib reduces the working radius and makes it easier to adapt the crane configuration to the space constraints of the jobsite.
Jobsites with space or oversailing restrictions
On jobsites surrounded by buildings, with tight property lines or areas that cannot be oversailed, one of the main constraints is the space the crane takes up when it is out of service.
In this situation, the crane must be left in weathervane mode, allowing the slewing part to turn freely with the wind. As a result, the out-of-service radius can determine both the choice of crane type and its position and configuration on the jobsite.
Beyond this constraint, luffing jib cranes offer an additional advantage during operation: they can adjust their working radius by raising the jib, which makes them easier to use in settings with nearby buildings, property lines or other obstacles.
You can find out more about this configuration in our range of luffing jib tower cranes.
When even the out-of-service radius is critical
On the most space-constrained jobsites, hydraulic luffing jib cranes offer an additional solution.
The LCH300, for example, can reduce its radius while maintaining a maximum reach of 60 meters and a load capacity of up to 16 metric tons.
In addition, its slewing part can be transported in 7 trucks or containers, which makes logistics easier on jobsites with difficult access.
You can find out more about its features in our Hydraulic Luffing series.
Comparison of the three types of tower crane
This summary sets out the main differences between the three types of crane and the situations each one is usually best suited to.
| Flat-Top | Luffing jib | Hydraulic luffing jib | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jib movement | Horizontal jib; a trolley travels along it to position the load. | The jib itself changes its angle to adjust the working radius. | The jib itself changes its angle to adjust the working radius. |
| Main advantage | High productivity, simple erection and dismantling, and less clearance needed between jibs. | Adjustable working radius and greater ability to work in space-constrained settings. | Easy erection and dismantling; very small out-of-service radius. |
| Space required | Requires enough radius for the jib to slew, both in service and out of service. | Allows the working radius to be adjusted and reduced to suit jobsite conditions. | Especially suitable when the out-of-service radius is also very limited. |
| Typical applications | Industrial projects, logistics hubs, large infrastructure and jobsites with several cranes. | Urban jobsites, projects with oversailing restrictions, cranes in close proximity and high-rise buildings. | Tightly enclosed jobsites and projects with severe space and access constraints. |
| COMANSA range | LC Series | Luffing Series | LCH300 – Hydraulic Luffing Series |
Choosing the right crane starts with analyzing the jobsite
There is no single configuration that suits every project. The required working radius, the presence of obstacles, oversailing restrictions, height, interaction with other cranes and the space available both in service and out of service are some of the factors that determine which solution is best suited.
That is why, at COMANSA, we offer a range that includes Flat-Top, luffing jib and hydraulic luffing jib cranes, able to meet different installation and operating needs.
If you have a project underway, our engineering team can help you analyze its requirements and determine which configuration best fits the actual conditions on the jobsite.
You can get in touch with us through our contact page.